The method Practice Situation Navigator Guides Caregiver First Aid The course Field Notes For professionals About Get the free guide
dementia situation navigator

She's Suspicious of Everyone, Not Just About Theft

A steadier ground guide to suspicion that has spread past the missing purse. What is underneath it, what to say when you are the one being accused, and how to stay safe. Two things before anything else: if this arrived over hours or days she needs a doctor today, and if there is a gun in the house, move it out tonight.

Notice how much it stings to be the one she's suspicious of. Being cast as the threat by someone you've never stopped protecting is its own specific injury, and it deserves a breath before you try to talk her out of it.

R

What May Be Happening

Read

Before anything else: how fast did this start? Suspicion that appears or sharply worsens over hours or days, especially with drowsiness or alertness that swings through the day, is not a behavior. It is delirium until proven otherwise, and she needs to be seen the same day rather than booked in.

A brain that cannot retrieve where the purse was set down will still produce an explanation, and the explanations available are the ones that fit the evidence in the room. The purse is gone. Someone was here. Someone took it. That is a gap being filled rather than a judgment being formed, which is why arguing the facts so rarely works. Delusions are common, affecting something like a third of people with Alzheimer's at some point, though the studies range widely enough that no single number is worth trusting.

The specific forms are far less frightening once they have names. Capgras is the belief that a spouse or adult child has been replaced by an impostor, reported in around one in six people with Alzheimer's and more often in Lewy body dementia. Phantom boarder is the belief that someone unseen is living in the house. Mirror sign is not recognizing her own reflection. Television can stop being a representation and become an event happening in the room. Accusations of infidelity are usually about fear of abandonment rather than about sex.

Capgras deserves its own line, since it targets the person emotionally closest, which is why it lands on you, and in one case series people with Alzheimer's and Capgras were more than twice as likely to show aggression. That makes it a safety matter. If there is a gun in the house, this is the paragraph to act on: someone who does not recognize you and believes an intruder is in her home may act on that belief, and the Alzheimer's Association's guidance is to move firearms out of the house rather than into a safe. The same logic applies to car keys and, if she has ever reached for one, kitchen knives.

One distinction changes what happens next. A delusion is a belief that will not shift. A hallucination is seeing or hearing something that is not there. If she is seeing people, children or animals in detail, and particularly if that began early in the illness, that points toward Lewy body dementia, and the clinician needs to hear it in plain words because it changes which medications are safe.

Then check the ordinary things. Pain drives more distressed behavior than anything else you can fix. Uncorrected hearing and vision loss feed suspicion directly, since a person who hears voices in the next room but not the words will supply the words. Medications belong on the list too, particularly bladder drugs and sedating antihistamines, opioids, steroids, Parkinson's medications, and anything recently stopped, including alcohol.

And one uncomfortable thing has to be said. When the accusation names a specific paid caregiver, check before you dismiss it. Do not leave her alone with that person while you do. Look for unexplained bruising, money that does not add up, and distress that appears only around one person. Nearly all of these accusations are the illness. Not all of them are, and Adult Protective Services through the Eldercare Locator, 1-800-677-1116, is where it goes if you find something.

R

What to Say

Reach
"That sounds frightening. I'm here."
Answer the fear rather than the claim, since the fear is the real thing.
"I know that you see something, but I don't see it."
The Alzheimer's Association's phrasing, and it works because it is neither an argument nor a lie.
"Let's look for it together."
Turning the accusation into a shared search removes the standoff without anyone having to be right.
"I'll go and check."
Acting on the concern settles more than reassurance does, since reassurance asks her to take your word against her own senses.
"Tell me about him. What was he like?"
When she believes you have been replaced, insisting on your identity fails, and asking about the person she is missing reaches the feeling underneath.
If She Is Frightened of You
Move out of the doorway.
Do not stand between her and the way out, and do not touch her to prove who you are, since both raise the pressure at the moment it is already highest.
Step out, then come back in as though arriving.
The delusion is usually about you in that moment rather than about you permanently, and a break is often enough to reset it.
Let someone else take over if anyone else is there.
Capgras attaches to one person and frequently does not transfer, so a second person can often do the care you cannot.
If she is escalating and you cannot get past her, leave the house and call for help.
Being wrong about how bad it was going to get costs you nothing. Being right and staying costs a great deal.
What Not to Say
"Nobody took it. You put it somewhere and forgot."
The memory of setting it down does not exist to be corrected, so the correction lands as proof that nobody believes her.
"It's me. Look at me. I'm your husband."
Insisting on identity raises the pressure without changing the belief, and this is the delusion most often paired with aggression.
"There's nobody in the house. You're imagining it."
This asks her to distrust the only evidence she has, which produces fear rather than relief.

What to Try Next

Look for the cause before you reach for the technique, since most of what drives this is findable.

RChange Your ApproachReach
  1. Check pain, then hearing and vision. A person who cannot hear the room will fill in the gaps, and the fill is rarely generous. Working hearing aids and clean glasses are an intervention here rather than an accessory.
  2. Reduce what there is to misread. Close the curtains after dark so the window stops producing a stranger, keep news and crime drama off, and put a lamp on in the corner she watches. Cover a mirror only if her own reflection distresses her.
  3. Keep duplicates of whatever goes missing. Two purses, two sets of reading glasses, a little cash somewhere she can find it. This ends more accusations than any explanation.
  4. Take the medication list to the pharmacist and ask what on it could be causing this, since anticholinergics, opioids, steroids and recent stops are all common and all reversible. Do not stop anything yourself.
NTrack the PatternNotice

Write down when it happens, what was going on twenty minutes before, and who it names. If it clusters late in the day, the fix belongs earlier in the afternoon. If it names one particular person every time, check rather than dismiss. And if the pattern changed shape over days rather than months, that belongs on the phone rather than in a notebook.

She still knows you. What has failed is the part of the brain that attaches the feeling of familiarity to a face, and the person underneath is still there and still attached to you, which is why the delusion landed on you rather than on a stranger. Being accused of stealing, or of being an impostor, by someone you have cared for is one of the cruelest things this illness does, and it lands harder because it arrives wearing your own name. It is not what she thinks of you. It is what her brain assembled to explain a gap. For most families this eases over months rather than continuing forever, which is worth holding onto. Tell someone what happened today rather than carrying it alone.

N

When to Call a Clinician

Notice

Call Today, Non-Urgent

  • The suspicion is new, or has clearly intensified over the past week or two
  • She is seeing people, children or animals that are not there, particularly if this started early in the illness
  • She seems low or hopeless as well as suspicious, or the accusations are getting in the way of care, sleep, or letting anyone into the house

Seek Care Now

  • It appeared or worsened over hours to days, especially with drowsiness or alertness that swings through the day. That is delirium until proven otherwise and she needs to be seen today, not next week
  • She believes you are an impostor and is frightened enough that either of you could be hurt. Leave the house and call 911 if you cannot get past her safely
  • Fever, new confusion beyond how she normally is, or a recent medication change alongside the suspicion
If an antipsychotic is proposed, both of these are true and they are not equally well established. The harm is measured: in a large study of older adults with dementia, six months of treatment was associated with roughly two to four extra deaths per hundred people, worst with haloperidol and risperidone, and the risk rises with the dose. The benefit is narrower than it sounds, since it comes from a secondary analysis of one trial in which most participants stopped the drug. Ask whether pain, constipation, infection, delirium and recent medication changes have been ruled out first, since guidance requires that. Ask for the lowest dose and a review date no more than six weeks out. And say this out loud even if you assume it is in the notes: could this be Lewy body dementia? If it could, several standard antipsychotics can cause a severe and occasionally fatal reaction, and the prescriber needs to know before writing it.
Situation guides on this page reflect clinically accepted dementia care practice and Matt Field's professional experience training care staff and families across Chicago-area senior living communities. They are practical guidance, not a substitute for medical advice specific to your situation. Last reviewed August 2026.